For now - 4 stars. The watch came in very nice packaging. Upon opening it, my first thought was, "Wow! It's a lot bigger than I thought it would be." Heavier, too. And to big for my 7 inch wrist. Also noted the little tab which keeps it from running had fallen out in the box so it was already running. Hadn't thought that I'd have to manually set the date and day, but only took a few minutes of spinning the hands around to set it. After some deliberation, I decided to give it a fair try as I really think it's very pretty and I like the day/date combination. Changing them manually at the end of each short month (less than 31 days) isn't that big a deal. I had a jeweler remove two links from the band and was informed this watch was made in China. Hmm... Anyway, I've gotten use to the weight of it fairly quickly and so far it's keeping good time. Still getting use to the size. Only "time" will tell if this is a good watch, or not.I've now had the watch for a couple months and it has kept time very well. I have gotten use to the size and now appreciate it being a bit bigger than expected as it's easy for me to see what time it is and the day and date. If it were smaller, the day and date would be hard to read. It has held up well, even after I've accidentally banged it a few times at work. Not dings, dents, scratches or cracks, thankfully. I am glad that I purchased this watch.It's been 5 months since I've bought this watch and my enthusiasm has run out and I've downgraded this to two stars. The pink/peach color (never could quite decide which it was) has worn off... literally! It now looks like every other gold and silver watch. The other issue is, I work in a hot environment and the watch now leaves black marks on my wrist when I sweat. Not sure what that's all about. Anyway, at this point, it still keeps good time and date, but I would not buy it again.